Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ray Savoie's avatar

You establish a vivid setting with this opening salvo.

One thing I wanted was to latch onto a character, whether that be a protagonist, antagonist, or merely a side quest NPC. I was interested and relieved when you mentioned the priest, but you kept the formal, distanced narration. The priest doesn't hear the confession of a specific steel worker; he hears it from all steel workers, who you then describe in toto. How about a particular steel worker? This person would ground the reader while also communicating everything you said about all the immigrant steel workers. What is this man’s “small mean[ness]”? How is it related to his occupation? Does he cough a lot, a symptom of his work in a mill? Does he hate his boss and/or his corporate overlord?

The writing is good though. On my first read I felt a bit bombarded by the lengthy descriptions of the city, but on rereads I came to appreciate the writing more.

I don't know if these thoughts are productive for you and I don't know if you land on a character immediately after this salvo. It's just what I yearned for while reading it. Take that as you may.

Solid description though. It reminded me of 1952's Great Smog of London, which was well visualized in the show The Crown.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts